B2B Mystery Shopper Case Study: Unveiling the B2B Mystery Shopping within AR Automation
In the competitive world of AR automation, you must know your competitors. You need to understand their strengths, weaknesses, and strategies. A global B2B client asked Octopus Intelligence to do a mystery shop. This B2B mystery shopper case study shows how we found useful insights. These insights helped our client to improve their strategy. They could then stand out and seize new opportunities in a fast-changing industry.
Background
A global B2B high-growth platform hired Octopus. They wanted insights into the AR automation market’s competitive landscape. They wanted to evaluate two competitors, A and B. So we focused on their pricing, features, and target markets. The goal was to inform the client’s strategy and boost their competitiveness.
What Was Happening
The AR automation market is competitive. Businesses want to streamline invoicing, payments, and collections. Competitor A claimed to be a complete, high-end solution. It had advanced automation and scalability. Competitor B, on the other hand, focused on customer-friendly payment tools. They had simpler pricing and faster implementation. The client needed to understand their competitors. This would help find gaps, strengths, and opportunities in their own offerings.
Key Questions
The client wanted us to address the following:
- How do Competitor A and Competitor B compare regarding features, pricing, and scalability?
- What are the strengths and limitations of each competitor’s platform?
- What market segments are they targeting?
- How can the client differentiate their offering to capture market share?
What We Did
We did a mystery shopping exercise to evaluate Competitor A and Competitor B. Here’s our approach:
- Data Collection
- I engaged directly with the sales and support teams of both competitors. We sought detailed pricing, features, and implementation information.
- Analysed publicly available materials, case studies, and testimonials for additional context.
- Feature Analysis
- Competitor A: They have a Unified AR Automation Platform. It includes invoicing, payments, cash applications, and collections.
- Competitor B: They focus on customer-facing payment solutions, like pay-by-text and auto-pay.
- Pricing Comparison
- Competitor A has a volume-based pricing model. It starts at $110,000 a year, plus a $50,000 implementation fee.
- I examined Competitor B’s pricing. It’s $495/month, with per-transaction fees but no implementation costs.
- Scalability and Market Fit
- We assessed Competitor A. It can handle a million monthly invoices, making it ideal for enterprises.
- We evaluated Competitor B for small-to-medium businesses. Its low cost and easy-to-use interface make it a good fit.
The Results
Our analysis revealed clear strengths and gaps in both competitors’ offerings:
Competitor A:
- Strengths: Comprehensive backend automation, advanced AI-driven collections, and scalability for high-volume enterprises.
- Weaknesses: Higher upfront costs and a longer implementation process.
- Target Market: Large enterprises needing end-to-end AR solutions.
Competitor B:
- Strengths: Frictionless payment tools, affordable pricing, and rapid deployment.
- Weaknesses: Limited backend features and scalability.
- Target Market: SMBs prioritising a seamless customer payment experience.
Our Recommendations
Based on our findings, we advised the client to focus on the following strategies:
Differentiate Through Customisation
Create modular solutions. They should combine enterprise-level automation with user-friendly tools. This will bridge the gap between Competitor A and Competitor B’s approaches.
Target Underserved Mid-Market Segments
Position the client’s offering as a scalable, cost-effective option for mid-sized businesses. It should fill the pricing gap between the two competitors.
Use Customer-Centric Features
To appeal to SMBs and enterprises, focus on:
- User-friendly payment interfaces.
- Fast deployment.
- Advanced automation for backend processes.
Offer Flexible Pricing Models
Introduce tiered pricing. It should support growth while staying affordable. It should be like Competitor A’s scalability and Competitor B’s transparency.
Invest in Marketing and Support
To stand out in a crowded market, highlight the client’s strengths: implementation, training, and 24/7 support.
Conclusion to this B2B Mystery Shopper Case study within AR
Our B2B mystery shoppers can give the client key insights into the AR automation market and its players. By studying Competitor A’s solutions and Competitor B’s payment tools, we found ways to stand out.
Our analysis showed that Competitor A excels in scalability and automation for large enterprises. However, its high costs and complex setup may deter some buyers. In contrast, competitor B offers small-to-medium businesses a cheap, efficient solution. However, it lacks the automation and scalability that larger organizations need.
We gave the client actionable recommendations based on these findings. They should bridge the gap between the two approaches. They want to attract mid-sized and large businesses. These firms seek both efficiency and ease of use. We emphasized modularity, flexible pricing, and top-notch customer support. The client can now gain a competitive edge in this dynamic market.
This case study shows that B2B mystery shoppers can be a powerful tool for clarifying complex, competitive markets.
Octopus Intelligence specialises in uncovering actionable insights to empower businesses in competitive markets. This case study shows that knowing competitors can drive innovation and market leadership. Let us help you make smarter decisions.
We are Octopus. The Global People-Powered Competitive Intelligence Agency.
Outsmart your competition. Make the unknown known. Octopus helps you gain clarity in complex markets. With clients and tentacles around the world, we deliver sharp, actionable competitive intelligence through a blend of deep primary (HUMINT) and secondary research. If you’re looking to make smarter decisions, beat the competition, and reduce uncertainty, we’re the partner you want on your side.
