Niche Focus: Strategy for Overcoming Market Leader Advantages Part 2

This is a picture of a dog with a bone for an article called Niche Focus Strategy for Overcoming Market Leader Advantages by octopus competitive intelligence agency market intelligence company

Niche Focus: Strategy for Overcoming Market Leader Advantages Part 2

In the intricate landscape of market dynamics, confronting a dominant market leader head-on can be daunting. However, Strategy 2, the Niche Focus approach, offers an alternative avenue that thrives on precision and differentiation. By targeting niche markets often overlooked by industry giants, smaller players can carve out their domain and flourish. This strategy acknowledges that the entire market leader’s realm need not be the battlefield. Instead, success can be achieved by mastering a specific segment, building a loyal customer base, and redefining the rules of engagement.

Focus on niche markets rather than directly challenging the entire market leader’s domain. Due to their scale, these overlooked segments might not be as attractive to market leaders. Allowing smaller players to dominate and build a solid customer base.

Does anyone fancy an overpriced razor?

Example: Harry’s vs. Gillette. Harry’s targeted the men’s grooming market with a subscription-based model. They are offering a cost-effective alternative to Gillette’s expensive razors. Harry’s gained a loyal customer following by honing in on a specific audience.

Harry’s market entry as a subscription-based model ignited a revolution. Offering a compelling alternative to Gillette’s high-priced razors. What set Harry’s apart was its astute focus on a specific audience. Capturing the hearts of a loyal customer base seeking both value and convenience.

How to Define Your Target Market

At the heart of Harry’s triumph was its subscription-based approach. This is a radical departure from the traditional model championed by Gillette. By recognising routine purchases was ripe for reinvention with the power of subscriptions. Granting customers a seamless and predictable supply of grooming essentials. This disruption bypassed the inconvenience of repetitive shopping trips. At the same time, introducing cost savings that resonated with a new generation of consumers.

Gillette, long synonymous with premium grooming, was challenged by this unconventional approach. Gillette’s high-quality razors held a storied legacy. But they always carried a price tag that seemed disproportionate to what customers got. The entry of Harry’s signalled a paradigm shift. They redefined the cost-benefit equation. They caused traditional players to evaluate the sustainability of their pricing models.

Audience was important

However, Harry’s innovation wasn’t solely about affordability. It was about finely tuning its offerings to a specific audience. Harry’s cultivated a new customer base by zeroing in on men seeking value and convenience. A customer base that felt distinctly understood and catered to. This emotional connection was woven into the fabric of the brand story. Fostering loyalty that transcended transactional interactions.

Their strategy resonates with millennials seeking budget-friendly alternatives. And with a broader consumer base frustrated by the sticker shock of premium razors. Harry’s approach shattered a key perception. Quality was directly proportional to price. Telling customers illustrates that innovation and value could coexist harmoniously.

Harry’s didn’t just present an alternative. It created a tailored solution that catered to a distinct set of:

  • Needs
  • Aspirations
  • Frustrations 

This approach reframed the dynamics of the market. Rewriting the rules and propelling Harry’s into the spotlight as a challenger. Introducing convenience and affordability and creating a new narrative around grooming.

Sold out

Harry’s razor sold out to Edgewell Personal Care, the Schick brand of shaving products owner, in May 2019 for $1.4 billion. That’s Wilkinson’s Sword to you and me. The acquisition was intended to help Edgewell compete with other direct-to-consumer shaving companies like Dollar Shave Club, which Unilever had acquired for $1 billion in 2016.

Edgewell was attracted to Harry’s because of its strong brand and ability to reach young men online. Harry’s has also successfully expanded its product line beyond razors to include other men’s grooming products, such as shaving cream, deodorant, and body wash.

The acquisition of Harry’s was not without controversy. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sued to block the deal, arguing that it would reduce competition in the shaving market. However, the FTC ultimately backed down and allowed the value to go through.

Since the acquisition, Harry’s has continued to operate as an independent brand within Edgewell. The company’s founders, Andy Katz-Mayfield and Jeff Raider remain in charge of Harry’s and have said they plan to continue innovating and growing the brand.

Why did they sell to Edgewell?

Here are some of the reasons why Harry’s razor sold out to Edgewell:

  • To gain access to Edgewell’s distribution channels and manufacturing capabilities.
  • To compete with other direct-to-consumer shaving companies like Dollar Shave Club.
  • To raise capital for future growth.
  • To allow the founders to cash out and retire.

The sale of Harry’s to Edgewell is a sign of the changing landscape of the shaving industry. Direct-to-consumer companies are increasingly challenging traditional brands, and mergers and acquisitions are becoming more common. So both Dollar Shave Club and Harry’s were bought by their competitors, still pretending to be edgy and innovative, but are a massive company. Nothing wrong with that, of course, but not sure how you can be a rebel when owned by your daddy, who just pats you on the head. Confused messaging, exasperated by the fact you can buy a Harry’s razor in every supermarket or chemist.

Niche Focus Strategy for Overcoming Market Leader Advantages Part 2

The Niche Focus strategy is a beacon of innovation and specialization in business. Harry’s triumph over Gillette, rooted in this approach, is a testament to the power of strategic focus and tailored solutions. As we navigate the strategies for overcoming market leader advantages series, remember that conquering giants isn’t solely about brute force—it’s about precision, innovation, and understanding that in business, finding your niche can be the key to unlocking untold opportunities and reshaping industries. Stay tuned for the next chapter that unveils yet another strategic tool in the arsenal of market challenger success.

Let’s talk…

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Home » Blog » Using Competitive Intelligence » Niche Focus: Strategy for Overcoming Market Leader Advantages Part 2

What is competitive intelligence?

The collection and analysis of information to make sense of what’s happening, what's next, and what you can do to enhance your competitive advantage.

This is a drawing of the Octopus Intelligence Logo By Octopus Competitive Intelligence, Due Diligence, Competitor Analysls, Market Analysis, Competitor Research and Strategic Business Development to beat your competitors, increase sales and reduce risk

Want to know more about market and competitive intelligence and how it can help you beat your competitors?

We find the answers to beat your competitors, make better decisions, win more business and see what’s next. Since 2008, Octopus has been at the forefront of people-powered competitive intelligence solutions, helping brands, enterprises, high-growth SaaS companies, and startups. Globally, we have undertaken hundreds of competitive intelligence projects, providing straight-talking, actionable intelligence and cutting through the clutter with clear, concise deliverables.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.