Argument mapping in competitive intelligence to test your thinking

This is an image of two people arguing for an article called Argument mapping in competitive intelligence to test your thinking by octopus competitive intelligence solutions octopus competitor analysis services

Argument mapping in competitive intelligence to test your thinking

Argument mapping is a structured approach to testing hypotheses through logical reasoning. Mapping claims, evidence, and counterpoints helps clarify and dissect complex arguments. It not only aids in visualising the structure of reasoning but also enhances the robustness of decision-making by finding gaps and untested assumptions. Argument mapping is especially valuable in contexts like market and competitor analysis. It ensures that decisions are based on solid evidence rather than intuition or bias.

Logical reasoning

Argument Mapping is used to test a single hypothesis through logical reasoning. It involves simply writing down statements. Then, think about and put arguments for and against them for a reason. Argument mapping is structured and systematic. It helps us visualise the structure reasoning for a hypothesis. To dissect and clarify complex arguments by logically sequencing the following:

  • Claim
  • Evidence
  • Counterpoint

How to do it

Here’s how it usually works:

  1. Identify the Hypothesis. Create a concise statement covering the hypothesis or main claim you’re looking at.
  2. Create Supporting Arguments. Break down supporting arguments into sub-claims or reasons that bolster the central hypothesis.
  3. Consider Counterarguments. Integrate opposing viewpoints to test the resilience and validity of each hypothesis. This highlights weaknesses in the logic or evidence.
  4. Link Evidence. Add relevant data, research, or examples which back each argument or counterargument.
  5. Iterate and Refine. As you refine your map, you may uncover new sub-claims by pulling on the strings of information you find. Isolate arguments that are more solid than initially thought. And then keep going through this process, strengthening the logical framework.

Identify gaps

By mapping arguments, you can see your overview. This helps identify logical gaps or assumptions that could weaken any hypothesis. It makes the reasoning process more transparent and reveals blind spots, leading to more rigorous decision-making.

In market or competitor analysis, argument mapping helps confirm or throw out hypotheses. It helps clarify market trend assumptions and critically test different strategic options. It ensures that the logic behind your moves. And that the decisions are not based on intuition or bias. It provides you with a better sense of security in decisions. More certainty and less anxiety.

Visual Overview and Identification of Logical Gaps

Argument mapping is a powerful visual representation of your reasoning. It can illustrate how different claims and evidence interconnect. A view that helps you spot logical gaps or untested assumptions that might go unnoticed. Many arguments can rely on assumptions. Stuff that needs to be backed up by data or ignoring the evidence contradicts what you want to see. This transparency allows you to identify potential undermining weak points in your hypothesis. So, you can strengthen your arguments by filling these gaps with more evidence. Or by adjusting your thinking. Read More: Strategies for Marketing, Testing, and Expanding Your Company

Transparency in Reasoning and Revealing Blind Spots

The visual clarity of argument mapping makes the reasoning process more accessible to others. It also fosters collaboration and constructive criticism. It reveals overlooked blind spots caused by cognitive biases, incomplete information, or limited perspectives. This collective insight encourages thorough and rigorous decision-making, making everyone feel more engaged and supportive of decisions.

Assumptions about market trends often drive strategic decisions. However, these assumptions are sometimes based on incomplete, outdated, or simply wrong data. Mapping arguments clarify assumptions by highlighting the evidence supporting each trend prediction. We can then assess the validity of our assumptions and refine our strategic models accordingly.

Critically Evaluating Strategic Options

Argument mapping is also a valuable tool for critically evaluating different strategic options. When assessing the strengths and weaknesses of introducing new product lines, maps show the logic of each option, making it easier to compare strategies side-by-side. This reveals which choice is best supported by evidence and which only relies on weaker assumptions.

It’s more than a process

Argument mapping is not just a process. It’s a powerful tool that can bring significant benefits to your decision-making. Visually laying out reasoning helps:

  • Identify logical gaps
  • Challenge assumptions
  • Bring transparency to your strategic planning
  • Validates strategic hypotheses

It ensures strategies are insight-driven rather than intuition-based. Augment mapping is indispensable for rigorous decision-making.

Argument mapping to test your thinking

Argument mapping is a powerful tool for improving decision-making. It does this by providing a clear visual representation of reasoning. It highlights logical gaps, challenges assumptions, and brings transparency to planning. And integrates supporting arguments, counterarguments, and relevant evidence, so any hypotheses are insight-driven. It fosters collaboration and reveals cognitive blind spots, leading to more rigorous and well-supported decisions. We all live in a world where clarity and precision are paramount, so argument mapping is indispensable for validating options and enhancing decision-making.

Let’s talk…

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Home » Blog » Analysing competitive intelligence » Argument mapping in competitive intelligence to test your thinking

What is competitive intelligence?

Competitive intelligence is the finding & critical analysis of information to make sense of what’s happening & why. Predict what’s going to happen & give the options to control the outcome. The insight to create more certainty & competitive advantage.

This is a drawing of the Octopus Intelligence Logo By Octopus Competitive Intelligence, Due Diligence, Competitor Analysls, Market Analysis, Competitor Research and Strategic Business Development to beat your competitors, increase sales and reduce risk


We Find The Answers To Beat Your Competitors

Bespoke, people-powered competitive intelligence to create insight you can do something with. We help you be more competitive, beat your competitors and win more business.

But enough about us, let's here about you:

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.